Unpopular Take: It Is OK if Schumer Leads
Published at 10:33 on 18 November 2026
Hear me out on this. I know just what a stereotypically useless milquetoast Democrat the guy is. If that was the only factor, I would oppose him, too.
The issue, however, is that the current situation is mostly performative, thanks to the enormous power of the imperial presidency, which now exists mostly above, and superior to, any written law. Therefore, in terms of policy outcome, it matters less than many think who controls Congress for the next two years: Trump is mostly going to get his way, and the Democrats in Congress will mostly be limited to grumbling about it. Harsh but true.
Two years on and in all likelihood, the extra cuts in the so-called “big beautiful bill” will have kicked in, the business cycle will not be in a favourable phase, the Iran war will remain unresolved, and anyone involved in the status quo will be tainted with all of the above. The latter includes the Democratic leadership in Congress. As such, better to have the old guard get besmirched with the taint than any new insurgents.
The leadership debate is, in other words, much like an argument between two young children over who gets the booby prize: both want to “win” a “prize” but have no idea as to the true nature of what a booby prize is.
Where we are is mostly in a performative space, politically speaking. It does make sense for progressives to raise a stink about the likes of Schumer and Jeffries, but raising the stink itself is the main point. Ditto for attempting investigations: attempt them as hard as possible, gather as much data as possible, but expect the investigations to, for various reasons, not accomplish much. (And note that a lot of these investigations will be in the hands of committee chairs, not the majority leader. It is important to get the do-nothing contingent out of these seats.)
The points should be to keep both the corruption of the Trump regime and the inevitable ineffectualness of the Democratic Party leadership in the public eye as much as possible. Then start campaigning against both as primary season ramps up.
Any real progress will have to wait until after the next presidential election, and the more the Establishment is tainted with failure, the better the progressives can be expected to do.