ROK vs. USA: Study in Contrasts
Published at 10:12 on 14 December 2024
The Republic of Korea, more commonly known as South Korea, just demonstrated itself to have a much healthier political culture than the so-called leader of the free world. It’s not even remotely a close call.
President Yoon Suk Yeol, frustrated at a National Assembly that refused to do his bidding, declared martial law, accusing his opponents of being “communists” (a frequent screed launched by conservatives at their opponents, whether or not actual communism is at play).
It hasn’t gone so well for Yoon or his government since then. The National Assembly promptly reconvened (challenging soldiers who were attempting to block the entrance to its Proceeding Hall), and unanimously voted to revoke the declaration. Yes, a unanimous vote, including Assembly members who belonged to the same party as the president. None of this falling in line behind Yoon like the US Republicans fall in line behind Trump.
It’s not been a picture perfect response. The logical next step is to impeach the fascist who just tried to destroy democracy. On that, there was foot-dragging, due to opposition from parliamentarians in the president’s own party. But recently, enough of them were persuaded to cross the aisle to get the necessary supermajority for impeachment.
Advocates of martial law within Yoon’s administration are also being dealt with. And by “being dealt with,” I mean being treated like the accused criminals they are: arrested, detained, and charged with crimes in preparation for their trials. Not so much of the endless hand-wringing about whether or not the powerful should be held to account that plagues US political culture. The Republic of Korea is still apparently a nation of laws, not men.
I must point out here that there is no Get Out of Criticism Free card for the USA by virtue of its political polarization. South Korea is also a highly polarized society. Its president and legislature were deadlocked for months; this deadlock was in fact the motive for martial law attempt. Yet, in spite of the polarization, enough Koreans from across that polarized political spectrum have been able to unite in defence of the basic premises of an open and free society.
By contrast, the big news out of the USA is that Biden decided to pardon his own son and that Trump is highly likely to get virtually every last massively unqualified fascist toady he wants on his Cabinet.
That former point handily vindicates my earlier decision to be personally done with the Democratic Party. It is an institution that has proven itself time and again be not an opponent of democratic decline, but instead a willing co-participant in it. Any hope for the USA depends on the emergence of the sort of “none of the above” grassroots movement of which I have written earlier.
So please, spare me any garbage about American exceptionalism. The only things exceptional about today’s America are its low morals and advanced state of political decline.