Political This and That
Published at 09:06 on 5 July 2025
Quite a bit has happened this week, which I have yet to comment on.
Carney Cravenly Caves
Oh, sure, there’s technically a chance it was, as Carney’s apologists say, all pre-planned. But let’s get real here. Occam’s Razor says it is far more likely to be just what it appears to be, which is just what I said it was in the title for this section.
What’s particularly worrying is not the specific policy caved on, but the general policy area of the cave; namely, regulating social media. There has long been something toxic to a free and open society about social media. The Trump era, with the US capitalist class lining up in support behind fascism, as the capitalist class inevitably does, makes the problem all the more acute. What once was a bug is now most definitely a feature. You can take it to the bank that the social media giants are doing their level best to make their algorithms as fascism-friendly as possible.
As such, it is incumbent on the remaining free societies of the world to regulate the hell out of these social media giants. (There is a right way and a wrong way to do this, which I will get into sometime.)
Now Carney has just had Canada concede to its hostile neighbour that yes, it is only reasonable for Canada to accommodate that neighbour’s wishes when it comes to social media. This is precisely the wrong sort of precedent to be setting.
It is the year 1950 in an alternate history timeline. The USSR is trying to gain control over domestic US media via dummy holding companies. Would the United States have just sat there while the USSR gained control of CBS and NBC? Yet this is basically the analogue of what Carney has now set precedent that Canada do. Social media are that influential in public opinion.
The Enabling Act
It’s a crude analogue, because decades-long precedents and trends, plus recent friendly Supreme Court rulings, have accomplished a lot of it, but if anything is the American analogue to the Enabling Act, it is how the big ugly bill has allocated an obscene and shocking amount of money to the ICE gestapo (long one of the most powerful and least accountable law enforcement agencies). The first concentration camp, the so-called Alligator Alcatraz, has already opened, and Trump fascists are gleefully celebrating America’s new Dachau with commemorative merchandise.
You can take it to the bank that those camps will not only be used for oppressing immigrants.
Lots of people smell the corpse now.
Left Rhetorical Incompetence
If the political Left had any rhetorical competence, the alliterations “big bad bill” and “alligator Auschwitz” would now be entering common use. It’s seemingly a little thing, but it’s not really a little thing: good labelling and sloganeering matter a lot in politics.
Zohran Mamdani Is in Personal Peril
Odds are that within two years, he will either be dead, disappeared, incarcerated, under house arrest, or in exile. Because of course he will be. Authoritarian states do not stand idly by and let true opposition arise.
Since (overall, individual exceptions do not disprove the general rule) the Democratic Party has been a co-participant in, not an opponent of the USA’s transition to fascism, it may well be allowed to continue existing. Authoritarian regimes often allow sham opposition parties, and the Democratic Party has long been effectively functioning as such voluntarily, anyhow. A transition to a more formal arrangement would thus represent a relatively minor change.
The real question is whether, and how much, the paradox of repression manifests when the inevitable happens to Mamdani.